Articles producció científica> Gestió d'Empreses

The weight of organizational factors on heuristics: Evidence from triage decision-making processes

  • Datos identificativos

    Identificador: imarina:5610976
    Autores:
    Barberà-Mariné MCannavacciuolo LIppolito APonsiglione CZollo G
    Resumen:
    © 2018, Emerald Publishing Limited. Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to investigate the influence of organizational factors on individual decision-making under conditions of uncertainty and time pressure. A method to assess the impact of individual and organizational factors on individual decisions is proposed and experimented in the context of triage decision-making process. Design/methodology/approach: The adopted methodology is based on the bias-variance decomposition formula. The method, usually applied to assess the predictive accuracy of heuristics, has been adjusted to discriminate between the impact of organizational and individual factors affecting heuristic processes. To test the methodology, 25 clinical scenarios have been designed and submitted, through simulations, to the triage nurses of two Spanish hospitals. Findings: Nurses’ decisions are affected by organizational factors in certain task conditions, such as situations characterized by complete and coherent information. When relevant information is lacking and available information is not coherent, decision-makers base their assessments on their personal experience and gut feeling. Research limitations/implications: Discriminating between the influence of organizational factors and individual ones is the starting point for a more in-depth understanding of how organization can guide the decision process. Using simulations of clinical scenarios in field research does not allow for capturing the influence of some contextual factors, such as the nurses’ stress levels, on individual decisions. This issue will be addressed in further research. Practical implications: Bias and variance are useful measurements for detecting process improvement actions. A bias prevalence requires a re-design of organization
  • Otros:

    Autor según el artículo: Barberà-Mariné M; Cannavacciuolo L; Ippolito A; Ponsiglione C; Zollo G
    Departamento: Gestió d'Empreses
    Autor/es de la URV: Barberà Mariné, Maria Glòria
    Palabras clave: Bias and variance error Cognition Cognitive heuristic Design Dynamics Frugal Individual cognition Information Judgment Nurses Organizational factors Rationality Strategy Triage Uncertainty
    Resumen: © 2018, Emerald Publishing Limited. Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to investigate the influence of organizational factors on individual decision-making under conditions of uncertainty and time pressure. A method to assess the impact of individual and organizational factors on individual decisions is proposed and experimented in the context of triage decision-making process. Design/methodology/approach: The adopted methodology is based on the bias-variance decomposition formula. The method, usually applied to assess the predictive accuracy of heuristics, has been adjusted to discriminate between the impact of organizational and individual factors affecting heuristic processes. To test the methodology, 25 clinical scenarios have been designed and submitted, through simulations, to the triage nurses of two Spanish hospitals. Findings: Nurses’ decisions are affected by organizational factors in certain task conditions, such as situations characterized by complete and coherent information. When relevant information is lacking and available information is not coherent, decision-makers base their assessments on their personal experience and gut feeling. Research limitations/implications: Discriminating between the influence of organizational factors and individual ones is the starting point for a more in-depth understanding of how organization can guide the decision process. Using simulations of clinical scenarios in field research does not allow for capturing the influence of some contextual factors, such as the nurses’ stress levels, on individual decisions. This issue will be addressed in further research. Practical implications: Bias and variance are useful measurements for detecting process improvement actions. A bias prevalence requires a re-design of organizational settings, whereas training would be preferred when variance prevails. Originality/value: The main contribution of this work concerns the novel interpretation of bias and variance concepts to assess organizational factors’ influence on heuristic decision-making processes, taking into account the level of complexity of decision-related tasks.
    Áreas temáticas: Administração pública e de empresas, ciências contábeis e turismo Administração, ciências contábeis e turismo Business Business, management and accounting (all) Business, management and accounting (miscellaneous) Ciencias sociales Economia Engenharias iii General business,management and accounting Interdisciplinar Management Management science and operations research
    Acceso a la licencia de uso: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/es/
    Direcció de correo del autor: gloria.barbera@urv.cat
    ISSN: 00251747
    Identificador del autor: 0000-0003-2578-1301
    Fecha de alta del registro: 2023-02-18
    Versión del articulo depositado: info:eu-repo/semantics/acceptedVersion
    Enlace a la fuente original: https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/MD-06-2017-0574/full/html
    Referencia al articulo segun fuente origial: Management Decision. 57 (11): 2890-2910
    Referencia de l'ítem segons les normes APA: Barberà-Mariné M; Cannavacciuolo L; Ippolito A; Ponsiglione C; Zollo G (2019). The weight of organizational factors on heuristics: Evidence from triage decision-making processes. Management Decision, 57(11), 2890-2910. DOI: 10.1108/MD-06-2017-0574
    URL Documento de licencia: https://repositori.urv.cat/ca/proteccio-de-dades/
    DOI del artículo: 10.1108/MD-06-2017-0574
    Entidad: Universitat Rovira i Virgili
    Año de publicación de la revista: 2019
    Tipo de publicación: info:eu-repo/semantics/article
  • Palabras clave:

    Business,Business, Management and Accounting (Miscellaneous),Management,Management Science and Operations Research
    Bias and variance error
    Cognition
    Cognitive heuristic
    Design
    Dynamics
    Frugal
    Individual cognition
    Information
    Judgment
    Nurses
    Organizational factors
    Rationality
    Strategy
    Triage
    Uncertainty
    Administração pública e de empresas, ciências contábeis e turismo
    Administração, ciências contábeis e turismo
    Business
    Business, management and accounting (all)
    Business, management and accounting (miscellaneous)
    Ciencias sociales
    Economia
    Engenharias iii
    General business,management and accounting
    Interdisciplinar
    Management
    Management science and operations research
    00251747
  • Documentos:

  • Cerca a google

    Search to google scholar